Unlocking the Power of Collaborative Learning: A Comprehensive Guide

Collaborative learning is a powerful educational approach that emphasizes teamwork and cooperation among students. It involves creating opportunities for learners to work together towards a common goal, leveraging their diverse perspectives, knowledge, and skills to achieve better results. By fostering a sense of community and shared responsibility, collaborative learning promotes active engagement, critical thinking, and problem-solving. In this comprehensive guide, we will explore the concept of collaborative learning, its benefits, and provide practical examples to help you unlock its full potential in your educational journey.

What is Collaborative Learning?

Defining Collaborative Learning

Collaborative learning is an educational approach that emphasizes the active participation of students in the learning process. This approach involves a group of individuals working together to achieve a common goal, enabling them to learn from one another’s perspectives, experiences, and knowledge. Collaborative learning is characterized by open communication, mutual support, and a shared sense of responsibility among team members.

Some key features of collaborative learning include:

  • Small group work: Collaborative learning often involves breaking students into small groups, which allows for more focused and in-depth discussions.
  • Equal participation: Each member of the group is encouraged to contribute their ideas and opinions, fostering a sense of ownership and engagement in the learning process.
  • Interdependence: Students rely on one another to complete tasks and achieve the desired outcome, promoting a sense of responsibility and accountability.
  • Active listening and communication: Collaborative learning requires students to actively listen to one another and communicate effectively, enhancing their social and emotional skills.
  • Problem-solving: Collaborative learning often involves solving complex problems or completing projects, which helps students develop critical thinking and problem-solving skills.

By incorporating collaborative learning into the classroom, educators can create a more dynamic and engaging learning environment that encourages student interaction, cooperation, and creativity. This approach also promotes the development of important life skills such as teamwork, communication, and conflict resolution.

Advantages of Collaborative Learning

Collaborative learning has been widely recognized as an effective and powerful approach to education. By working together in small groups, students are able to actively engage with course material, develop critical thinking skills, and improve their overall academic performance.

Increased Retention of Information

One of the primary advantages of collaborative learning is that it promotes deeper understanding and longer-lasting retention of information. When students work together to solve problems or complete projects, they are forced to think critically and creatively, which helps them to internalize the material and remember it for longer periods of time.

Improved Social Skills

Collaborative learning also provides opportunities for students to develop their social skills, such as communication, negotiation, and conflict resolution. By working in groups, students learn how to listen to and respect the opinions of others, how to share ideas and resources, and how to work towards a common goal.

Enhanced Problem-Solving Abilities

Another benefit of collaborative learning is that it enhances students’ problem-solving abilities. When students work together, they are able to approach problems from different perspectives and bring a variety of skills and knowledge to the table. This diversity of thought and expertise can lead to more creative and effective solutions.

Increased Motivation and Engagement

Finally, collaborative learning has been shown to increase motivation and engagement among students. When students feel a sense of ownership over their learning and are able to contribute their own ideas and perspectives, they are more likely to be engaged and motivated to learn.

Overall, the advantages of collaborative learning are numerous and varied. By incorporating collaborative learning strategies into the classroom, educators can create a more dynamic and engaging learning environment that promotes deeper understanding, improved social skills, enhanced problem-solving abilities, and increased motivation and engagement among students.

Examples of Collaborative Learning

Collaborative learning is a powerful educational approach that fosters student engagement, enhances problem-solving skills, and promotes the development of social and emotional competencies. To better understand the concept, it is essential to examine various examples of collaborative learning in action.

  1. Group Projects: One of the most common forms of collaborative learning is working on group projects. Students are divided into small groups and assigned a task or problem to solve. They are responsible for dividing the work, setting goals, and holding each other accountable for meeting deadlines. Through this process, students learn to work together, share ideas, and develop critical thinking and problem-solving skills.
  2. Peer Tutoring: Peer tutoring is another example of collaborative learning. In this approach, students work together to help each other learn. This can take many forms, such as a student who is struggling with a particular subject helping another student who understands the material. Peer tutoring not only promotes learning but also fosters a sense of community and cooperation among students.
  3. Collaborative Problem-Solving: Collaborative problem-solving involves students working together to solve a complex problem or challenge. This approach requires students to brainstorm, discuss, and evaluate ideas, ultimately leading to a more comprehensive understanding of the problem at hand. Collaborative problem-solving can be particularly effective in subjects such as science, mathematics, and engineering, where students must work together to design solutions to real-world challenges.
  4. Cooperative Learning: Cooperative learning is a structured approach to collaborative learning that involves students working in small groups to achieve a common goal. Each group member is responsible for a specific role, such as summarizer, questioner, or recorder. This approach encourages active participation, fosters a sense of accountability, and promotes collaboration among students.
  5. Online Discussion Boards: In today’s digital age, online discussion boards have become a popular platform for collaborative learning. Students can share ideas, ask questions, and provide feedback to their peers in a virtual environment. This approach is particularly useful for distance learning and can foster a sense of community and engagement among students who may not be physically present in the same classroom.

By examining these examples of collaborative learning, educators can gain a better understanding of how to effectively implement this approach in their classrooms. Through collaboration, students can develop critical thinking skills, problem-solving abilities, and a sense of community and cooperation that will serve them well in their academic and professional lives.

Collaborative Learning Platforms

Key takeaway: Collaborative learning is an educational approach that emphasizes active participation of students in the learning process. Collaborative learning has several advantages, including increased retention of information, improved social skills, and enhanced problem-solving abilities. Collaborative learning can be implemented both offline and online, and effective collaboration requires a supportive learning environment, clear objectives, adequate resources, active participation, and regular feedback and evaluation. The future of collaborative learning involves the integration of new technologies, teaching methods, and pedagogical approaches that prioritize student-centered learning and promote active learning and lifelong learning.

Online Collaborative Learning Platforms

Introduction to Online Collaborative Learning Platforms

Online collaborative learning platforms are digital tools designed to facilitate communication, interaction, and collaboration among students, educators, and content. These platforms have gained significant traction in recent years due to their ability to support remote and hybrid learning models, fostering collaboration in a virtual environment.

Benefits of Online Collaborative Learning Platforms

  1. Accessibility: Online collaborative learning platforms provide learners with anytime, anywhere access to educational resources and communication tools, enabling them to participate in learning activities regardless of their location.
  2. Flexibility: These platforms offer flexibility in terms of time and pace, allowing learners to work at their own pace and schedule, catering to different learning styles and preferences.
  3. Enhanced Collaboration: Online collaborative learning platforms provide learners with opportunities to connect and collaborate with peers and educators from diverse backgrounds, promoting cultural awareness and global competencies.
  4. Real-time Feedback: These platforms facilitate real-time feedback and communication between learners and educators, fostering a supportive and engaging learning environment.

Key Features of Online Collaborative Learning Platforms

  1. Virtual Classrooms: These platforms offer virtual classrooms that simulate traditional classroom environments, allowing learners to participate in live discussions, interactive presentations, and group activities.
  2. Collaboration Tools: Online collaborative learning platforms provide learners with tools such as chat, discussion boards, and document sharing, enabling them to work together on projects and share knowledge.
  3. Content Management: These platforms offer content management systems that allow educators to upload, organize, and share educational resources, facilitating a seamless learning experience.
  4. Assessment and Analytics: Online collaborative learning platforms provide educators with assessment and analytics tools, enabling them to track learner progress, identify areas of improvement, and adjust instructional strategies accordingly.

Selecting the Right Online Collaborative Learning Platform

When selecting an online collaborative learning platform, it is essential to consider factors such as:

  1. Ease of Use: The platform should be user-friendly and intuitive, requiring minimal training and support.
  2. Compatibility: The platform should be compatible with various devices and operating systems, ensuring that learners can access it from any device.
  3. Cost: The platform should be cost-effective, offering a balance between affordability and functionality.
  4. Customer Support: The platform should provide reliable customer support, offering assistance and resources to ensure a smooth learning experience.

In conclusion, online collaborative learning platforms play a vital role in facilitating communication, interaction, and collaboration among learners and educators in a virtual environment. By leveraging these platforms, educators can create engaging and interactive learning experiences, fostering collaboration and enhancing the overall learning process.

Offline Collaborative Learning Platforms

While online collaborative learning platforms have gained significant attention in recent years, offline collaborative learning platforms remain a valuable tool for enhancing the learning experience. Offline collaborative learning platforms are designed to facilitate group learning without the need for an internet connection. These platforms provide learners with opportunities to engage in meaningful discussions, share ideas, and work together to solve problems.

Benefits of Offline Collaborative Learning Platforms

Offline collaborative learning platforms offer several benefits that make them an essential component of the learning process. These benefits include:

  1. Accessibility: Offline collaborative learning platforms are accessible to learners who may not have access to reliable internet connections or who live in areas with limited internet access.
  2. Flexibility: Offline collaborative learning platforms can be used in a variety of settings, including classrooms, libraries, and community centers, providing learners with greater flexibility in their learning environment.
  3. Improved Social Skills: Offline collaborative learning platforms encourage learners to communicate and work together, promoting the development of social skills and teamwork.
  4. Enhanced Critical Thinking: Offline collaborative learning platforms require learners to engage in active listening, problem-solving, and decision-making, enhancing their critical thinking skills.

Types of Offline Collaborative Learning Platforms

There are several types of offline collaborative learning platforms, each designed to meet the unique needs of learners. These platforms include:

  1. Group Discussion: This type of platform allows learners to engage in face-to-face discussions, sharing ideas and perspectives on a particular topic.
  2. Problem-Solving: This type of platform requires learners to work together to solve problems, promoting critical thinking and creativity.
  3. Collaborative Projects: This type of platform encourages learners to work together on a project, allowing them to share ideas, resources, and expertise.
  4. Debate: This type of platform provides learners with the opportunity to engage in debates, honing their argumentation and persuasion skills.

Implementation of Offline Collaborative Learning Platforms

To implement offline collaborative learning platforms effectively, it is essential to consider several factors, including:

  1. Goals and Objectives: Define clear goals and objectives for the learning experience, ensuring that learners understand the purpose and value of the platform.
  2. Learner-Centered Approach: Ensure that the platform is learner-centered, allowing learners to take an active role in the learning process.
  3. Materials and Resources: Provide learners with the necessary materials and resources to facilitate collaborative learning, including textbooks, articles, and multimedia resources.
  4. Evaluation and Assessment: Establish clear criteria for evaluating and assessing learners’ progress, providing feedback and guidance as needed.

In conclusion, offline collaborative learning platforms offer a valuable tool for enhancing the learning experience, providing learners with opportunities to engage in meaningful discussions, share ideas, and work together to solve problems. By implementing offline collaborative learning platforms effectively, educators can promote active learning, enhance critical thinking skills, and foster social and emotional growth in learners.

Choosing the Right Collaborative Learning Platform

When it comes to choosing the right collaborative learning platform, there are several factors to consider. The first factor to consider is the learning objectives and goals of the course or program. It is important to choose a platform that aligns with these objectives and goals.

Another important factor to consider is the type of learners that will be using the platform. Some platforms may be better suited for visual learners, while others may be better suited for auditory learners. It is important to choose a platform that caters to the learning style of the majority of the learners.

The level of interaction and collaboration required is also an important factor to consider. Some platforms may offer more interactive features, such as video conferencing and chat rooms, while others may be more focused on content delivery. It is important to choose a platform that provides the level of interaction and collaboration needed for the course or program.

Additionally, the cost of the platform is also an important factor to consider. Some platforms may be more expensive than others, and it is important to choose a platform that fits within the budget of the course or program.

Lastly, it is important to consider the technical requirements of the platform. Some platforms may require specific hardware or software, and it is important to choose a platform that is compatible with the technology available.

In conclusion, when choosing a collaborative learning platform, it is important to consider the learning objectives and goals, the type of learners, the level of interaction and collaboration, the cost, and the technical requirements. By carefully considering these factors, educators can choose a platform that will best support the learning needs of their students.

Implementing Collaborative Learning

Preparing for Collaborative Learning

Establishing a Supportive Learning Environment

Collaborative learning requires a supportive learning environment that encourages open communication, active participation, and constructive feedback. Here are some steps to help you prepare for collaborative learning:

  1. Set clear goals and expectations: Establishing clear goals and expectations for collaborative learning can help students understand the purpose and benefits of working together. It is important to communicate the objectives of the collaboration, the roles and responsibilities of each student, and the expected outcomes.
  2. Create a positive and inclusive atmosphere: A positive and inclusive atmosphere is essential for effective collaboration. Encourage open communication, respect different perspectives, and celebrate diversity. Provide opportunities for students to get to know each other and build trust, which can help foster a sense of community and collaboration.
  3. Facilitate active participation: Encourage active participation from all students by providing opportunities for them to contribute their ideas and perspectives. Use icebreakers, group discussions, and interactive activities to engage students and help them feel comfortable working together.
  4. Develop effective communication skills: Effective communication is essential for successful collaboration. Teach students how to communicate effectively, listen actively, and provide constructive feedback. Encourage students to share their ideas and perspectives openly and respectfully, and to ask questions and seek clarification when needed.
  5. Establish ground rules: Establishing ground rules can help create a safe and productive learning environment. Encourage students to participate in creating the rules, which can help ensure that they are meaningful and effective. Ground rules should cover topics such as respect, active listening, and constructive feedback.

By following these steps, you can help create a supportive learning environment that encourages open communication, active participation, and constructive feedback, which are essential for successful collaborative learning.

Building Effective Collaborative Learning Environments

Creating an environment that fosters collaboration is essential for the success of collaborative learning. The following are some key factors to consider when building effective collaborative learning environments:

Establishing Clear Objectives

The first step in building an effective collaborative learning environment is to establish clear objectives. These objectives should be specific, measurable, achievable, relevant, and time-bound (SMART). By setting clear objectives, learners will have a clear understanding of what they are working towards, and this will help them stay focused and motivated.

Providing Adequate Resources

Providing adequate resources is another critical factor in building effective collaborative learning environments. This includes providing access to technology, materials, and equipment that learners need to complete tasks and achieve objectives. It is also essential to ensure that these resources are accessible and user-friendly, so learners can use them effectively.

Creating a Supportive Learning Culture

Creating a supportive learning culture is crucial for the success of collaborative learning. This includes fostering a culture of trust, respect, and open communication. Learners should feel comfortable sharing their ideas and feedback with one another, and instructors should encourage this by creating a safe and inclusive learning environment.

Encouraging Active Participation

Encouraging active participation is another essential factor in building effective collaborative learning environments. Instructors should create opportunities for learners to actively participate in the learning process, such as through group discussions, peer review, and problem-solving activities. This will help learners stay engaged and motivated and promote a sense of ownership over their learning.

Providing Feedback and Evaluation

Providing feedback and evaluation is critical for the success of collaborative learning. Instructors should provide regular feedback to learners on their progress and performance, and this feedback should be timely, specific, and actionable. Evaluation should also be done regularly to assess the effectiveness of the collaborative learning environment and make any necessary adjustments.

In conclusion, building effective collaborative learning environments requires careful consideration of several key factors, including establishing clear objectives, providing adequate resources, creating a supportive learning culture, encouraging active participation, and providing feedback and evaluation. By taking these factors into account, instructors can create collaborative learning environments that promote engagement, motivation, and success.

Facilitating Collaborative Learning

As an educator, facilitating collaborative learning can be a powerful tool to promote deeper understanding and foster critical thinking skills in students. However, it requires careful planning and execution to ensure that it is effective. Here are some key considerations when facilitating collaborative learning:

Creating a Supportive Environment

Before students can engage in effective collaboration, they need to feel safe and supported. This means creating a classroom environment that values diversity, encourages respectful dialogue, and promotes positive relationships among students. Teachers can do this by establishing clear expectations for behavior, providing opportunities for students to get to know each other, and modeling respectful communication themselves.

Setting Clear Goals and Objectives

Collaborative learning should be goal-oriented and focused on achieving specific outcomes. Teachers should set clear goals and objectives for each collaborative activity, and communicate these to students. This helps students understand the purpose of the activity and stay focused on the task at hand. It also helps teachers assess the effectiveness of the activity and make adjustments as needed.

Encouraging Active Participation

Collaborative learning requires active participation from all students. Teachers can encourage participation by assigning roles and responsibilities, providing opportunities for students to share ideas and feedback, and creating activities that are engaging and relevant to students’ interests and experiences. Teachers can also use strategies such as think-pair-share and group discussions to encourage participation and foster deeper understanding.

Providing Feedback and Assessment

Providing feedback and assessment is crucial to the success of collaborative learning. Teachers should provide feedback to students on their contributions and progress towards the goals of the activity. This can be done through formal assessments, informal observations, and peer evaluations. Teachers should also provide opportunities for students to evaluate each other’s contributions and provide feedback to each other.

Adapting to Challenges and Adjustments

Collaborative learning is not always smooth sailing. Teachers should be prepared to adapt to challenges and adjust their approach as needed. This may involve modifying the activity, providing additional support or resources, or adjusting the group dynamics. Teachers should also be flexible in their expectations and recognize that not every collaboration will be successful.

In summary, facilitating collaborative learning requires careful planning, execution, and adaptation. By creating a supportive environment, setting clear goals and objectives, encouraging active participation, providing feedback and assessment, and adapting to challenges and adjustments, teachers can help students unlock the power of collaborative learning and develop critical thinking skills that will serve them well in the future.

Assessing Collaborative Learning Outcomes

When it comes to assessing the outcomes of collaborative learning, it is important to keep in mind that there are many different methods and approaches that can be used. The key is to choose an assessment method that is aligned with the goals and objectives of the collaborative learning experience, and that provides meaningful feedback to both the students and the instructor.

One common approach to assessing collaborative learning outcomes is to use a rubric. A rubric is a tool that outlines the criteria for evaluating student work, and provides a clear set of guidelines for determining the level of proficiency achieved by each student. Rubrics can be used to assess a wide range of collaborative learning activities, including group projects, group presentations, and group discussions.

Another approach to assessing collaborative learning outcomes is to use self-assessment. Self-assessment involves asking students to evaluate their own performance and learning, and to provide feedback to their peers. This approach can be particularly effective in promoting a deeper understanding of the learning process, and in helping students to develop a sense of ownership over their own learning.

It is also important to consider the role of formative assessment in assessing collaborative learning outcomes. Formative assessment is a process that involves ongoing evaluation of student learning and progress, and is used to inform instructional decisions and adjustments. By using formative assessment techniques, instructors can provide feedback to students in a timely manner, and can adjust their teaching strategies to better meet the needs of the students.

Ultimately, the goal of assessing collaborative learning outcomes is to provide feedback that is meaningful and actionable for both the students and the instructor. By using a variety of assessment methods and approaches, instructors can gain a more complete picture of student learning and progress, and can use this information to improve the effectiveness of their collaborative learning experiences.

Tips for Successful Collaborative Learning

  • Establish clear goals and expectations:
    • Begin by defining the learning objectives and desired outcomes for the collaborative activity.
    • Clearly communicate the purpose and relevance of the task to the students.
    • Encourage students to reflect on their individual learning goals and how they align with the group’s objectives.
  • Create a supportive environment:
    • Foster a culture of mutual respect, trust, and open communication among students.
    • Encourage active listening and constructive feedback.
    • Provide opportunities for students to practice empathy and perspective-taking.
  • Promote active participation and engagement:
    • Encourage students to take turns leading discussions and sharing ideas.
    • Assign roles and responsibilities to students, such as facilitator, note-taker, or timekeeper.
    • Use strategies like think-pair-share and small group work to encourage interaction and collaboration.
  • Encourage diversity of thought and perspective:
    • Encourage students to share their unique experiences and viewpoints.
    • Foster a culture of inclusivity and respect for diverse backgrounds and perspectives.
    • Use strategies like the “round robin” technique, where each student takes a turn to share before anyone else can speak.
  • Monitor and assess progress:
    • Regularly check-in with students to assess their understanding and progress.
    • Provide feedback and support as needed.
    • Adjust the activity or group dynamics if necessary to ensure all students are engaged and benefiting from the experience.

The Future of Collaborative Learning

Emerging Trends in Collaborative Learning

  • The integration of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in collaborative learning environments to enhance student engagement and personalized learning experiences.
  • The use of Virtual Reality (VR) and Augmented Reality (AR) to create immersive and interactive learning experiences that promote collaboration and problem-solving skills.
  • The rise of microlearning, where small chunks of content are delivered in short, focused sessions, allowing for more flexible and accessible learning opportunities.
  • The increased use of gamification in education, where learning is made more engaging and fun through the use of game-like elements such as points, badges, and leaderboards.
  • The growth of online and remote collaborative learning, as technology allows for more opportunities for students to connect and collaborate with peers from around the world.

Challenges and Opportunities in Collaborative Learning

As the world continues to evolve, so does the field of education. One of the most promising developments in recent years is the rise of collaborative learning, a teaching method that emphasizes teamwork and interaction among students. However, as with any new approach, there are both challenges and opportunities associated with this method.

One of the biggest challenges in collaborative learning is managing group dynamics. It can be difficult to ensure that all students are equally engaged and contributing to the group, and some students may dominate discussions or fail to participate at all. Additionally, some students may struggle with communication or interpersonal skills, which can make it difficult for them to work effectively in a group setting.

Despite these challenges, there are also many opportunities associated with collaborative learning. For one, it allows students to develop important social and communication skills that will serve them well in the future. It also encourages critical thinking and problem-solving, as students must work together to come up with solutions to complex problems. Furthermore, collaborative learning can help to foster a sense of community and collaboration among students, which can improve overall classroom dynamics and lead to a more positive learning environment.

In order to effectively implement collaborative learning in the classroom, it is important to carefully consider the specific goals and objectives of the lesson, as well as the needs and abilities of the students. Teachers should also provide clear guidelines and expectations for group work, and should be prepared to adapt their approach as needed based on the progress and dynamics of the group. By addressing these challenges and capitalizing on the opportunities associated with collaborative learning, teachers can help to create a more engaging and effective learning environment for their students.

Preparing for the Future of Collaborative Learning

As we look towards the future of collaborative learning, it is essential to understand that the landscape of education is rapidly evolving. To prepare for the future of collaborative learning, educators must be willing to adapt and integrate new technologies, teaching methods, and pedagogical approaches.

Embracing New Technologies

One of the key ways to prepare for the future of collaborative learning is to embrace new technologies. These technologies can facilitate communication, enhance collaboration, and promote active learning. For example, learning management systems (LMS), virtual reality (VR), and augmented reality (AR) are some of the technologies that can be integrated into the classroom to enhance collaborative learning.

Teaching Methods and Pedagogical Approaches

Another important aspect of preparing for the future of collaborative learning is to adopt new teaching methods and pedagogical approaches. These methods and approaches should prioritize student-centered learning, where students are encouraged to take an active role in their own learning process. Some of these methods include project-based learning, inquiry-based learning, and flipped classrooms.

Promoting Active Learning

In addition to embracing new technologies and adopting new teaching methods, promoting active learning is critical in preparing for the future of collaborative learning. Active learning involves students actively participating in the learning process, rather than passively receiving information. This can be achieved through various strategies such as problem-solving, group work, and peer teaching.

Encouraging Lifelong Learning

Finally, preparing for the future of collaborative learning requires encouraging lifelong learning. This involves creating a culture of continuous learning, where students are encouraged to develop skills and competencies that will prepare them for the ever-changing world. Educators can promote lifelong learning by incorporating real-world problems and challenges into the classroom, fostering a growth mindset, and providing opportunities for students to engage in self-directed learning.

By embracing new technologies, adopting new teaching methods and pedagogical approaches, promoting active learning, and encouraging lifelong learning, educators can prepare for the future of collaborative learning and create a more engaging, inclusive, and effective learning environment.

FAQs

1. What is collaborative learning?

Collaborative learning is a type of educational approach that involves students working together to achieve a common goal. This approach emphasizes teamwork, communication, and problem-solving skills.

2. What are the benefits of collaborative learning?

Collaborative learning has many benefits, including increased engagement, improved critical thinking skills, enhanced problem-solving abilities, and the development of social skills. It also encourages students to take responsibility for their own learning and to develop a deeper understanding of the material.

3. What are some examples of collaborative learning?

Examples of collaborative learning include group projects, peer review sessions, study groups, and group presentations. In each of these examples, students work together to achieve a common goal, such as completing a project or learning a new concept.

4. How can I implement collaborative learning in my classroom?

There are many ways to implement collaborative learning in the classroom, including setting up group projects, encouraging peer review sessions, facilitating study groups, and organizing group presentations. It is important to provide clear guidelines and expectations for students, and to monitor their progress to ensure that they are on track.

5. What are some tips for effective collaborative learning?

Some tips for effective collaborative learning include setting clear goals and objectives, providing opportunities for students to share their ideas and opinions, encouraging active participation from all members of the group, and facilitating open communication. It is also important to provide constructive feedback and to celebrate successes.

Collaborative Learning Builds Deeper Understanding

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *